Before sale proceeds are split, the court does an accounting. A co-owner who paid more than their share of the mortgage, taxes, insurance or necessary repairs can get credit for the excess. A co-owner who collected rent from third parties has to share it. The key is proof: a credit claim without proof of payment rarely survives.
I prepare credit and offset recommendations in most of my partition appointments. This is how the process works and what I look for.
The legal basis
The court “may, in all cases, order allowance, accounting, contribution, or other compensatory adjustment among the parties according to the principles of equity.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 872.140.) Courts treat this accounting as part of every partition: each co-owner’s charges and credits are settled before the net proceeds are divided. (Wallace v. Daley (1990) 220 Cal.App.3d 1028, 1035.)
The court often asks the referee to gather the claims and recommend how to treat them. The referee recommends and the court decides.
What usually earns a credit
These payments can be credited to the extent one co-owner paid more than their ownership share:
- Mortgage principal and interest
- Property taxes and assessments
- Hazard insurance
- Necessary repairs and maintenance that protected the property
- Down payment and closing costs at purchase, which are typically reimbursed before the remaining proceeds are split
Improvements are treated differently from repairs. The credit for an improvement is generally measured by the value it added to the property, not by what it cost. In Wallace, the improvement credit followed the increase in market value, not the amount spent. (Wallace v. Daley, supra, 220 Cal.App.3d at pp. 1035, 1038.)
What usually does not
- Your own labor. Time a co-owner spends managing or working on the property is generally not paid for, absent an agreement to pay for it. (Combs v. Ritter (1950) 100 Cal.App.2d 315, 317.)
- Furniture and personal property. These are not part of the real property being partitioned. Built-in fixtures and appliances are a different matter.
- Personal debts and family arrangements. Loans between family members, support obligations, and claims by people who are not parties to the case fall outside the partition accounting.
- Lost value from “mismanagement.” A claim that the other side’s choices reduced the property’s value needs real evidence, usually an expert, connecting the conduct to the loss.
Rent, possession and ouster
This is the most-argued issue in partition accounting. Every co-owner has the right to possess the whole property. A co-owner who lives there alone generally does not owe the others rent just for living there. (Estate of Hughes (1992) 5 Cal.App.4th 1607, 1611; Swartzbaugh v. Sampson (1936) 11 Cal.App.2d 451, 455.)
The exception is ouster: one co-owner wrongfully excluding the others. The California Supreme Court described ouster as conduct such as “claiming the whole for himself, denying the title of his companion, or refusing to permit him to enter.” (Zaslow v. Kroenert (1946) 29 Cal.2d 541, 548.) An ousted co-owner may recover their share of the value of the use and occupation from the time of the ouster. (Ibid.) The co-owner claiming ouster carries the burden of proving it. A single unanswered request to come by is rarely enough.
Rent collected from tenants is different. A co-owner who leases the property to a third party has to account to the other co-owners for that rent, by ownership share. (McWhorter v. McWhorter (1929) 99 Cal.App. 293, 296.)
How to present a credit claim
I evaluate every credit against three questions:
- Was it paid? An invoice shows a bill, not a payment. I need a cancelled check, bank or card statement, or receipt.
- Was it for this property? A payment to a vendor who also serves another property needs a clear tie to this one.
- Did it benefit all the owners? Necessary upkeep does. A remodel to one owner’s taste may not, or only to the extent it raised the value.
Submit your claim once, organized by category, with the proof attached and a running total. Late additions and increased amounts in later rounds are hard to justify. If records for a stretch of time are missing, say so and explain what you can show.
Related: How Is a Partition Referee Paid in California? and Buyout or Sale? How a California Partition Actually Ends.
Frequently asked questions
Do I get credit for paying the mortgage while my co-owner paid nothing?
Generally yes, for the amount you paid above your ownership share, with proof of payment. (Code Civ. Proc., § 872.140.)
My co-owner lived in the house for years. Do they owe me rent?
Not automatically. A co-owner in possession generally owes rent to the others only if they excluded them (ouster) or the parties agreed otherwise. (Estate of Hughes, supra, 5 Cal.App.4th at p. 1611; Swartzbaugh v. Sampson, supra, 11 Cal.App.2d at p. 455; Zaslow v. Kroenert, supra, 29 Cal.2d at p. 548.)
Are improvements reimbursed dollar for dollar?
Usually not. The credit for an improvement generally follows the value it added to the property. (Wallace v. Daley, supra, 220 Cal.App.3d at pp. 1035, 1038.)
Who decides the credits, the referee or the judge?
The judge. The referee gathers the evidence and recommends a treatment. If the parties agree, they can stipulate. If not, the court rules.
Amy Harrington has served as court-appointed partition referee in more than 100 matters across California. To propose her as referee, see her partition referee page, request her qualifications, or call 415-558-7700. This article is general information, not legal advice for any particular case.